Wednesday, June 16, 2021

Punishment vs Reinforcement

 

While there is a very limited and brief place for punishment, it typically is not as effective as reinforcement.  Unfortunately, the two are often confused with parents, teachers, others, believing they are punishing a child/teen/adult but are actually reinforcing negative or inappropriate behavior.

For example: If a child/teen craves interaction with his or her parents and only gets it when misbehaving, even though that interaction may seem punitive, the interaction may well be reinforcing.

Decades ago, I knew someone who would attack others and do some very gross and inappropriate behaviors.  He had been doing this for much of his life.  He lived in an institution and every time he would do something like this, he would be tied down in his bed or his arms would be put in tubes to stop the behavior.  While the behavior would stop for a short time, it would soon return.  Unfortunately, almost the only time anyone would touch or interact with him was when “punishing” him.


Fortunately, I was able to implement a different strategy and the behavior stopped in about a month.


(Remember: Nature abhors a vacuum.  Anytime… or almost anytime, you want to get rid of a negative or inappropriate behavior, it needs to be replaced with an appropriate behavior that fills the same or a similar need.)


No comments: